Category Archives: Antebellum North Carolina

1830: Sylvester Churchill to Henry William Griswold

Sylvester Churchill, ca. 1860

This letter was written by Sylvester Churchill (1783-1862) who began his military career at the outbreak of the War of 1812. He was appointed a 1st Lieutenant in the 3rd US Artillery and served with distinction, rising progressively in rank until 1847 when he was breveted Brigadier General for his services in the Mexican-American War. At the beginning of the Civil War he had been Inspector General for over 20 years. He retired in September 1861. He was married to Lucy Hunter (1786-1862).

The letter was adressed to Capt. Henry William Griswold (1795-1834), an 1815 graduate of the US Military Academy and a career artillery officer. At the time this letter was written in December 1830, he was in garrison at Ft. Monroe (Old Point Comfort, Va,) were he was Captain of the 3rd US Artillery. Griswold wrote a letter of recommendation for Edgar Allen Poe to enter West Point where Poe was stationed in 1828-29.

Churchill drafted the letter during the Holiday Season of 1830 in Wilmington, North Carolina, as indicated by the content and postal markings. While he does not disclose the specifics of his long-term assignment, it is evident that it pertained to military service, as he included the “Private” sheet directed to Griswold amidst what was likely official correspondence. He notes that his family was safely settled at Fort Johnson—a historic Revolutionary War fort situated on the Clinch River near Wilmington. His assignment may have been connected to Fort Caswell, which was under construction during that period. He hints at some fear of being “kilt dead by nigs” which explains why he kept his family at Fort Johnson. I’m not aware of any particular slave revolt at that time but, in general, there was a constant fear among slave owners throughout this period of slave uprisings as the slaves greatly outnumbered the white inhabitants. As a Northerner, his presence among a large slave population may have heightened his anxiety.

In the previous year Churchill had been on assignment to perform an assessment of the value of the Mount Dearborn Armory situated on an island in the Catawba River in Chester County. South Carolina. This armory was intended to be comparable to the ones built at Springfield and Harper’s Ferry but it was never fully completed and it was completely abandoned by 1825. Churchill was paid $8 a day for 8 days to determine the property value when it was sold back to the State of South Carolina. The state subsequently sold it to Daniel McCullough who built a cotton factory on the site which was destroyed by Sherman in 1865. [See: Mount Dearborn Armory]

T R A N S C R I P T I O N

Addressed to Capt. W. H. Griswold, Adjutant 1st Art., Old Point Comfort, Virginia

Private

[December 1830]
Dear Gris–

Your little note came & gave comfort. In haste I can only say now that we are all alive except the “killed and wounded” by which I mean not to say that all the young gentlemen are unhit by the eyes, cheeks, teeth, & charms of some beautiful young ladies. We have entertainment upon feast & jollification upon suppers in rapid succession, which with enough of duties, have left us very busy. Long may we enjoy these, say I, before we are kilt dead by the nigs. Give me the glory first, the fighting when I must—more especially as the latter will not come—never.

I appreciate all you said about Pat. & I have known Samp. & Trimble 1 before. Am much pleased with Mr. [ ]. Have requested that Mr. Williamson may be appointed sutler.

Leave my family for the present at Fort Johnston, but shall go down occasionally to see them—tomorrow, for the first time. They are all well. So is the modest, worthy Dimock & family & Simonson—and so, my dear fellow, is your fellow, — S. C.

Give me all the news I pray.

I open this at 7 in the evening 31st to say that Maj. Kirby has just arrived & well. My my respects to Col Hand’s, Worth’s family & all friends.


1 This was probably Isaac Ridgeway Trimble (1802-1888) who graduated from the US Military Academy in 1822 and was commissioned a 2nd Lt. of Artillery. He was and engineer and in the 3rd US Artillery before he left the service in 1832 to pursue a career in railroads. He became a Confederate General in the Civil War.

1851: Benjamin Grist to Allen Grist

This is an 1851 stampless folded letter (SFL) from Benjamin Grist, a barely literate slave overseer in rural southeastern North Carolina to his cousin, Allen Grist, a very wealthy (and much more educated) businessman and slaveowner (owning more than 100 slaves) then in Wilmington N. C. Benjamin writes his “cuzen”, (who was also the owner of the plantation on which Benjamin worked), to provide an update on his trials and tribulations in overseeing Allen’s vast ‘turpentine’ plantation (a major business in that part of NC at the time). Much of the letter deals with problems with some of the slaves, including running away and then having to be ‘punished’ after being caught and returned, e.g. ”I give tham 40 [lashes] a peas [apiece].”

The letter is postmarked Wilmington, N. C., but is datelined “St. Pauls,” N. C. It has a manuscript “Way 5” rate mark, meaning that, rather than being brought to the local post office, it was hand-carried to a mail carrier who had the city of Wilmington on his route.

The turpentine business of Benjamin and Allen Grist are covered extensively in the book “American Lucifers: The dark history of Artificial Light, 1750-1865”, published in 2020 by Univ. NC Press, and the winner of that year’s Beverige Award by the American Historical Association. The book covers the early southern turpentine industry—in particular the use (and abuse) of slaves who were the primary source of extracting the resin from pine trees (from which turpentine was distilled). In 1860, Grist was listed as owning $50,000 in real estate and $92,900 in personal property, including 109 slaves, making him the largest slaveholder in Beaufort County. A. & J. R. Grist, turpentine farmers, held $44,000 in real estate and $125,750 in personal property and owned 72 slaves. In addition, as estate administrator for minor children related to his wife, Grist controlled another 48 slaves, for a total of 229. His son James R. Grist owned individually 84 slaves, giving the Grists ownership and management of 313 slaves. They leased additional slaves from other owners. [Source: NCPedia]

For readers unfamiliar with the pine tar industry of North Carolina, I will provide the following paragraph written by Ralph Goodrich (my g-g-grandmother’s brother) when he traveled from north to south through the pine forest region in 1859:

“These forests at first seemed to be without inhabitants either of man or of animals, but as we advanced from the dwarf and sparsely scattered pine & oak, which bordered on the outskirts, we came unexpectedly upon busy workmen. The thick undergrowth of brambles & briers was cut out. The pines were chipped into grooves about ten feet from the ground from which its pitch was oozing and dripping into the troughs beneath. Several log houses are scattered about, the furnace & warehouse, & barrels filled with the resin piled in stately rows or jumbled in utter confusion. In the distance we see clouds of smoke rising from huge black stacks of earth, while workmen are busy felling trees. We are in the midst of the tar and turpentine manufacturers, & in the midst of soot, smoke, and dirt. The ebony looks still more black, & the white man assumes a dusky countenance. We seemed to be hemmed in by a barrier of limitless forest, & shut out from every breeze so refreshing to the feverish cheek. At night we lay in a hammock tormented by mosquitoes, & lulled to sleep by the endless rattle of the locusts and the melancholy strain of the whippoorwill.” [Source: The Ralph Leland Goodrich Diaries, 1859-1867]

A Civil War linkage to the Grist family is the later use of the Grist mansion in Washington, NC. (https://www.ncpedia.org/biography/grist-james-redding), as a Union hospital. It still exists as a bed-and-breakfast residence and is notable for its secret rooms and passages (which may or may not have been of use during the Civil War).

Residence of J. Grist, Esq., Harper’s New Monthly Magazine, North Carolina Illustrated., p 751

[Note: This letter is from the personal collection of Richard Weiner and was offered for transcription and publication on Spared & Shared by express consent.]

Transcription

St. Pauls, North Carolina
July 28, 1851

Cousin Allen,

Cane got home yesterday the 26th with Stanley & Fitch. Riley [?] came within six miles of home & slipped off and left the mule in the road & is gone. We pursued him that night and tracked him 10 miles on the other side of Fayetteville next morning & he quit the road. Gar, he is gone back again. You ought to of chained him [to] Stanley & Fitch. I give them 40 [lashes] apiece and put them to work & they are working very well.

Cousin Allen, you seem to raise great complaints against me about the negroes. You know I treat negroes well and does not miss use them. I will give you a true statement of Mrs. Howard’s negroes—Br___, Sal & B___ & ___ has not had a lick this year. John has had a light whipping—say 15 or 20 [lashes]. Griffin & Stafford has been whipped but they [ ]. Henry has had three whippings. James R[edding] Grist was here & had two of them put on him—the first one and the last one. The other I put on.

You [lecture?] to me for the wearing [of chains?] and if it is not done, you will be [disappointed?] and complain of me. I have done my very best to have the work done & to keep the negroes satisfactory.

Cane was mistaken about the warehouse. It was done & he has him working on the wagons ever since. It is so dry & hot here—nothing can stand. The corn is dying. I am 10 crops of boxes behind in my shipping for the want of barrels. I keep [ ] still running. James wrote you all about the business.

Last week the old boxes will ship about the same. They ship before the news ones and will not get quite as much. I shall do my very best to keep the business straight if possible. I shall write you a Sunday again.

Yours truly, — Benj. Grist

1854: Washington J. McConnel to Benjamin Mace

The following letter was written by Washington J. McConnel (1810-1885) of Greensboro, Guilford county, North Carolina. Washington was married to Jane E. Lindsay in March 1840. He was married a second time to Emily S. Sperry of Baltimore, Maryland in September 1846.

From census records we know that McConnel was a “merchant” in Greensboro for most of his life though I cannot find any additional details as to the nature of his business. He was known to be on the board of directors for a local insurance company and may have also dealt in real estate. Unfortunately, we can’t tell from the letterhead what the nature of his business was either except that he clearly kept a store or office in Goldsboro. Only his name, “W. J. McConnel” appears above the door.

McConnel wrote the letter to Elwon Benjamin Mace (1807-1865) who married Susanna Staton (1809-1854), and married second, Betsey Lane (1832-1874) in May 1854.

Transcription

Greensboro, [North Carolina]
December 27, 1854

Benjamin Mace, Esq.
Dear Sir,

Mr. Jolly is in want of a Negro woman & I have told him that you had one to hire & that I should not wait here. Any contract you make with Mr. Jolly is perfectly good and I will see it paid & I have no doubt you will find him a good hand to hire too.

Very respectfully yours, — W. J. McConnel

1850: Sarah (Gwyn) Brown to James Byron Gordon

The following letter was written by Sarah H. (Gwyn) Brown (1798-1889), the wife of Hamilton Brown (1786-1870) of Wilkesboro, Wilkes county, North Carolina. Sarah’s first husband was Nathaniel Gordon (1784-1829) who died when her son, James Byron Gordon—the recipient of this letter—was only six years old.

Sarah (Gwyn) Brown’s Grave, Wilkesboro, N. C.

Some readers may recognize James Byron Gordon (1822-1864), having gained a name of distinction while serving as a Confederate Brigadier General in the Civil War. He began his service under the command of General J. E. B. Stuart as Major of the 1st North Carolina Cavalry and was promoted as its Colonel. In September 1863 he was promoted to Brigadier General an assigned command of the North Carolina Cavalry Brigade, taking over a higher command when General Stuart was killed in the Battle of Yellow Tavern. He was mortally wounded in May 1864 north of Richmond. He never married. When this letter was written, James was representing Wilkes county as a Member of the N. C. General Assembly House of Commons (HC) at Raleigh, as indicated on the cover.

Sarah mentions James’ half brother, Hamilton “Allen” Brown (1837-1917) in her letter as well. Allen also served the Confederacy as Colonel of the 1st North Carolina Regiment. She also mentions another half-brother named Hugh Thomas (“Tom”) Brown (1835-1861). After graduating at Chapel Hill and receiving his lawyer’s license, Tom had only just begun to practice law in Van Buren, Arkansas, when the Civil War began and he was elected Captain of the Van Buren Frontier Guards (3rd Arkansas). He was killed on 10 August 1861 at Wilson’s Creek.

Transcription

Oakland
December 26, 1850

Being alone today and as usual thinking about my dear son, I concluded I would commit some of my reflections to writing. I do not suppose you had any idea your Mother would send any of her scribbling to Raleigh while you. were there knowing I am so little accustomed to letter writing.

James Byron Gordon (ca. 1850)

I was glad to see so much tenderness and affection breathed in your letters to Cal. Oh, how dear my children are to me and as I advance in life, I feel a deeper interest in their happiness. But where is the jewel to be found on earth. Some writer has said domestic happiness was the sole surviver of the fall. But this you have not tried yet. Neither do I see much prospect of it. If you were married and settled in life with a pious, sensible woman and a true Christian yourself, then I would say you were a happy man. We pass by the flowers and gather the thorns.

Carro [Caroline] is at [her sister] Ann’s. Mr. [Hamilton] Brown has rode off and Allen is out hunting. It has been a mild, still Christmas. We went to preaching yesterday. Heard a sermon from our circuit preacher Mr. Floyd. Had several addresses from the Sunday school children.

We have sent for Tom and look for him home tomorrow. There has been a considerable breakup in College owing to some misunderstanding between the President and some of the students. He has expelled some. Hugh Gwyn has come home and says [he] expects he will be expelled. Tom wrote to his Father [that] out of 25 from North Carolina, there was only 6 left and they were leaving every day. We thought it best to send for him forthwith. It is believed that the faculty are abolitionist. I do not know whether Tom will return or not. Hugh says he will go back if they do not expel him. 1

Well, my dear James, the old mill is gone at last. There has been the greatest freshet I have ever recollected of seeing. [It] tore up the banks some and thrown out a great deal more white sand. You must make up your mind before you come home what is to be done. It is bad getting on without the mill, or sell out and move to some new country where you can commence life with renewed energy. John and Ann are much I the spirit of moving. I hope you will get perfectly satisfied this winter with a public life.

Oh my son, keep a watch over yourself. Be aware of temptation and of dissipation of every kind. Touch not, taste not, handle not the unclean thing. Be as wise as a serpent and harmless as a dove.

James, do you recollect the last chapter you read for me from the old bible? If you do, get your noble and read it again for your Mother’s sake. It was the last chapter of Ecclesiastics. I hope, my son, you read your bible and take it as the man of your council. I know you have age and experience sufficient to direct your course without any of my council but none but a Mother knows the feeling of a Mother morning and evening upon my knees do I implore High Heaven for the welfare of my dear son that He will open his eyes, enlighten his mind, and lead him to life everlasting.

Your ever affectionate Mother, — Sarah H. Brown


1 I believe the unnamed college involved in this incident was Emory and Henry College where James B. Gordon had previously attended but not graduated. Tom Brown may have initially begun his college courses there as well before attending Chapel Hill. Hugh Alexander Gwyn (1830-1861) of Janesville, N. C., the author’s nephew, did attend the school and was a Senior (Valedictorian) in the Class of 1851. After graduation he took at position as a teacher at Woodlawn Academy in Salisbury, Tennessee, and died there on 16 June 1861. Unfortunately I cannot find anything in the school history or period newspapers describing the incident.

1854: Arete E. Johnson to “My dear Madam”

Mount Vernon in 1858. If you look closely you can see that timbers and ship masts are being used to prop up the piazza roof.

This incredible letter was penned by Miss Arete E. Johnson (1829-1904) of Louisburg, Franklin county, North Carolina. On 8 June 1859, when Arete was 30 years old, she became the second wife of James Hart Yarborough (1828-1860). He died the following the year and “though she was a very beautiful and much admired woman,” Arete never remarried. Arete’s 1904 obituary described her as “a fine type of antebellum Southern woman—soft of speech, gracious of manner, versatile of gifts, and a charming conversationalist; she gave the impression of a culture higher and better than that of the post-vellum commercial life of the ‘New South.’ She and a sunny and cheerful disposition and was, withal a genuine believer in the Christian religion. Her religious faith ran like a thread of gold throughout her whole daily life. She was a consistent member of the Episcopal church…No estimate can be made of the influence for good of a good woman’s life. It is a sad but very truth that the types of social southern life, exemplified by Mrs. Yarborough, are fast disappearing. [The Franklin Times, 7 October 1904]

Arete was the daughter of Wood Tucker Johnson (1802-1862) and Josephine Ann Stephon Outerbridge (1806-18xx) of Franklin County. Arete’s father was a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania Medical College but in later life he settled into the life of a gentleman farmer on his 950 acre plantation where he raised cotton and other crops. Prior to his death in 1862, Arete’s father willed her one quarter of the 71 family-owned slaves.

In 1854, when Arete was 25 years old, she was called upon by a member of the Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association (MVLA) to represent her county—Franklin county, N. C.—in a fund raising activity to purchase and thereby save the home and gravesite of George Washington. The following letter, in Arete’s own hand, was sent to some unidentified female resident of Franklin county with a copy of a circular that was printed by the MVLA providing the details of the association and its purpose. The name of the letter’s recipient would normally have been written at the lower left hand margin of the letter and has most likely been torn off the third page. In 1858, the Association began printing the “Mount Vernon Record” to document their activities and to record the amounts of monies raised in the states. Miss Johnson’s name appears among the more successful North Carolina collectors, having raised $241 through her efforts.

“If the men of America have seen fit to allow the home of its most respected hero to go to ruin, why can’t the women of America band together to save it?” In 1853, Louisa Bird Cunningham wrote these words to her daughter, Ann Pamela Cunningham, after seeing the decrepit state of George Washington’s home while traveling on the Potomac River. Inspired by her mother’s words, Cunningham took it upon herself to challenge the nation to save Mount Vernon. She founded the Mount Vernon Ladies’ Association in 1853 and by 1858 had raised $200,000 dollars to purchase the mansion and two hundred acres.

Transcription

Louisburg [Franklin county, North Carolina]
August 9th 1854

My dear Madam,

Though a stranger to you, I take the liberty of addressing you on a subject which I feel should make us friends and acquaintances, for it is one in which every person in the Union, whatever the station, or degree, age or sex, is equally interested—and this common cause should bind us all together in bonds as close as this between the dearest friends, causing us to set in concert in this important matter in which being united, we will succeed for “in union there is strength.”

The accompanying circular will explain the reason of my letter.

Mount Vernon, the home and grave of Washington is about to pass into the hands of strangers and perhaps in a few years, the precious remains of the “Father of his Country” will be desecrated and no man will be able to point out his sepulcher!

I am sure, my dear Madam, that this appeal will not be made to you in vain. Will you read this circular? and when imbued with its spirit, will you carry it around to your neighbors? and rouse the same spirit and energy that inflamed our revolutionary mothers and made them accomplish such deeds of heroism!

We are not called upon to rival them in those glorious acts! All that we are asked to do is to contribute out mite to assist in purchasing the Home of Washington in order that his last resting place may be sacred!

You will see by the circular that a lady is shown from each county to act as “Presiding Lady” of that county. I have received this appointment for the county of Franklin and my business is to cause the subscription list to be carried into every part of the county so that every woman and infant girl may have her name down for at least one dollar.

As it would be impossible for one lady to visit in person all the different parts of her county, she chooses a lady to act for her where she cannot go. I have selected you for this work, and I beg you, for the remembrance of our beloved Washington, to carry this around your neighborhood and induce every woman and girl to give something towards this good cause. It is thought that all could give one dollar, perhaps, some would give more. If a mother had several daughters, she might subscribe a dollar for each one, writing down the names under her own, in order that all may have a share in the work. It is advisable to collect the subscription at the time of procuring the name as this mode would prevent confusion and trouble hereafter. In case of great inconvenience, however, this might be omitted, taking care of course that “Paid” be written after the name of every person who does pay.

Will you undertake this cause with you whole heart and work while there is yet time? The women of Franklin are surely as patriotic as those of other sections of the State. I feel that they will not be behind hand in so good a cause.

Will you do all that you can immediately, and send the subscription list with the amount collected by some trusty person to yours, very respectfully, — Arete E. Johnson


Follow-up

Received the following response to an inquiry made at the Fred W. Smith National Library for the Study of George Washington at Mount Vernon:

“Thank you for sharing this document and transcription with us. This letter is particularly interesting because if the early date. The Ladies’ Association had been organized for less than a year when this was written and we don’t have much correspondence or other manuscripts from the earliest years in our archives. I’m attaching a Washington Circular which must be similar to the one Mrs. Johnson enclosed in her letter, but it cannot be the exact same because of the date (ours is dated November 1854 and the letter was written in August). We do not have an earlier form of the circular in our archives, but I now know that they printed other versions before this one. Thanks again for sharing the letter with me. If your friend decides to donate it, we would be thrilled to accept it. Best regards,– Rebecca Baird, Archivist”